Whatchamacallit A crisp peanut filling, with a layer of smooth caramel, all covered in milk chocolate, the Whatchamacallit Bar is a pure delight! Contains milk, peanuts, and soy. $2.95 Out of stock Related products Out of stock Butter Finger $2.95 Read more Out of stock Reese’s Big Potato Chip King Size $5.95 Read more Out of stock Nestle Crunch $2.95 Read more Out of stock Almond Joy $2.95 Read more